The Firing Line Forums - View Single Post

idek · August 31, 2012, 01:48 AM

If I'm reading this correctly, the subject heading isn't so much about the use of 3" vs 3.5" shells so much as it's about 3" chambers vs. 3.5" chambers. Is that correct?

I personally prefer a 3" chamber over a 3.5" chamber, since I never have a need for 3.5" shells. I too have wondered about short-shucking, but I suspect once you were used to the gun, it wouldn't be a problem.

Hopefully the gunsmith can sort out the problem with the 870. I wouldn't give up on it too quickly or question the platform. 870s are perhaps the most time-tested shotgun in the world.

Also, how do you intend to use the gun? You mention bears, so are you just thinking of a gun at the house or something you carry around outdoors? If you're planning to tote it around, the Benelli is about 10% heavier than the 870, and I would rather have the lighter option.

August 31, 2012, 01:48 AM	#2
idek Senior Member Join Date: August 20, 2009 Posts: 903	If I'm reading this correctly, the subject heading isn't so much about the use of 3" vs 3.5" shells so much as it's about 3" chambers vs. 3.5" chambers. Is that correct? I personally prefer a 3" chamber over a 3.5" chamber, since I never have a need for 3.5" shells. I too have wondered about short-shucking, but I suspect once you were used to the gun, it wouldn't be a problem. Hopefully the gunsmith can sort out the problem with the 870. I wouldn't give up on it too quickly or question the platform. 870s are perhaps the most time-tested shotgun in the world. Also, how do you intend to use the gun? You mention bears, so are you just thinking of a gun at the house or something you carry around outdoors? If you're planning to tote it around, the Benelli is about 10% heavier than the 870, and I would rather have the lighter option. Last edited by idek; August 31, 2012 at 01:53 AM.