The Firing Line Forums - View Single Post - Woollard v. Sheridan: Cert Denied

press1280 · October 15, 2013, 05:02 PM

I have to disagree, we do not yet have a circuit split. PR was their lower court, and CA7 dealt with a total carry ban. The other opinions like Kachalsky,exc. are weaseling out of confining the right to the home on paper, but in reality they are. I believe they're trying hard to avoid a split at all costs.
If we win with Richards/Peruta, we'll have split with Drake,Woollard, and Kachalsky.
If Palmer ever gets to the DC Circuit and we lose, it'll split with Moore. Those scenarios may be the key.

October 15, 2013, 05:02 PM	#347
press1280 Senior Member Join Date: May 17, 2012 Posts: 228	I have to disagree, we do not yet have a circuit split. PR was their lower court, and CA7 dealt with a total carry ban. The other opinions like Kachalsky,exc. are weaseling out of confining the right to the home on paper, but in reality they are. I believe they're trying hard to avoid a split at all costs. If we win with Richards/Peruta, we'll have split with Drake,Woollard, and Kachalsky. If Palmer ever gets to the DC Circuit and we lose, it'll split with Moore. Those scenarios may be the key.