|
So, in case anyone is interested, I have created a spreadsheet that compiles what I believe to be the pertinent data for comparing "apples to apples" when it comes to the "stopping power" of various pistols and cartridge options. Unfortunately, I could not get the data of the multiple columns to copy and paste over... if someone knows a better way for me to share this, I would be happy to oblige. In the meantime, here is a list. It starts with the smallest calibers/grain weighted bullet options, and ends up at the largest.
To decipher my data below, each different cartridge choice will have 6 total lines of data with it. For example, the first one in line is the 22 Magnum Cartridge, the second line is the 40 grain bullet weight, the third line is the 1100 feet per second velocity at the muzzle I would expect out of my Kel Tec PMR30 barrel, the 4th line is the calculated foot pounds of Energy at the muzzle, the 5th line is the calculated numerical designation on the TKO scoring system, and the 6th line is the calculated numerical designation on the KPS scoring system.
Then the following line after that is the data from my FN5.7x28mm... and so on and so on.
22 mag
40
1100
107.5
1.38
0.48
5.7x28
40
1533
208.79
1.93
0.94
5.7x28
40
1699
256.45
2.14
1.15
P3AT 380 Auto
102
787
140.32
4.07
1.61
P3AT 380 Auto
80
1020
184.86
4.14
1.66
P3AT BB hard cast
100
1061
250.03
5.38
2.81
340PD 38 special
110
1080
284.97
6.02
3.52
340PD 38 Special
158
800
224.59
6.45
3.98
340PD 38 special BB
125
1050
306.09
6.66
4.29
340PD 357
125
1088
328.64
6.94
4.61
Kahr CM9
124
1116
343.01
7.02
4.77
Kahr CM9
127
1117
351.94
7.19
5.01
LC9 BB hard cast
147
1021
340.35
7.61
5.61
P938 BB hard cast
147
1024
342.35
7.63
5.65
340PD 357 Mag
145
1055
358.45
7.8
5.83
340PD 38 special hard cast
158
989
343.25
7.92
6.08
9mm +p outdoorsman
147
1100
395.06
8.2
6.52
g43 with 5 inch barrel BB
147
1100
395.06
8.2
6.52
G26 3.5 barrel doubletap (estimated)
147
1105
398.66
8.24
6.58
G19 4inch Doubletap 9mm FMJ
147
1120
409.55
8.35
6.75
G17 4.5 inch Doubletap 9mm FMJ
147
1135
420.6
8.46
6.94
LCRx 3inch 38 special BB
158
1076
406.29
8.62
7.2
45 ACP +p
120
1420
537.42
8.64
7.24
SP101 38 special
158
1112
433.93
8.91
7.69
G19 960R
147
1200
470.15
8.95
7.75
charter bulldog 44spc
200
900
359.81
11.03
8.07
357 sig
180
1000
399.79
9.13
8.07
357 sig
147
1255
514.23
9.36
8.48
357 sig, 4 inch
125
1480
608.12
9.38
8.53
45 ACP Kahr PM45 BB
200
931
385.02
12
8.64
40S&W BB heavy
180
1038
430.75
10.68
8.7
45 ACP Kahr PM45 BB
185
1015
423.31
12.1
8.79
40S&W BB outdoorsman
200
969
417.09
11.07
9.36
g27 40S&W doubletap FMJ
200
990
435.37
11.31
9.77
G27 40S&W doubletap hard cast
200
1009
452.24
11.53
10.15
40SW 6 inch barrel
155
1320
599.84
11.69
10.43
45 ACP
185
1117
512.67
13.31
10.64
40S&W Underwood HC
200
1050
489.74
12
10.99
DT 9x25 Dillon hardcast 6inch barrel
180
1200
575.69
10.95
11.63
DT 9x25 Dillon 6 inch barrel
147
1495
729.72
11.15
12.04
40S&W doubletap FMJ 4.5 inch barrel
200
1100
537.49
12.57
12.06
40SW doubletap HC 4.5 barrel
200
1106
543.37
12.64
12.19
G29 10mm
180
1230
604.84
12.65
12.22
45ACP +p doubletap 5 inch barrel
255
875
433.62
14.38
12.41
40S&W doubletap HC 6 inch estimate
200
1150
587.46
13.14
13.18
G29 10mm outdoorsman
220
1050
538.71
13.2
13.3
jframe 3 inch 357 BB
180
1300
675.64
11.93
13.65
45 ACP +p
255
925
484.6
15.2
13.86
45 Super
200
1200
639.66
15.46
14.35
44 special
255
950
511.14
14.85
14.62
10mm heavy
180
1350
728.61
13.89
14.72
g29 doubletap HC
230
1075
590.34
14.13
15.23
g29 10mm doubletap 200gr hardcast
200
1240
683.01
14.17
15.33
45 Super g30s (stock lenght)
240
1040
576.55
16.08
15.53
G20 10mm outdoorsman
220
1140
635.02
14.33
15.67
357 Mag outdoorsman (5 inch barrel)
180
1398
781.34
12.83
15.78
45 Super
230
1100
618.11
16.3
15.95
g20 doubletap HC
230
1120
640.8
14.72
16.54
45 Super hand loads
185
1400
805.35
16.69
16.72
g20 doubletap HC
200
1300
750.71
14.86
16.85
45 super doubletap 5inch barrel
255
1030
600.86
16.92
17.19
10mm outdoorsman
220
1200
703.62
15.09
17.37
45 Super
255
1075
654.51
17.66
18.73
460 Rowland
185
1500
924.51
17.88
19.19
45 Super hand loads
215
1300
807.01
18.01
19.47
41 Mag
170
1650
1027.95
16.43
19.61
45 super
250
1150
734.33
18.52
20.6
40 Super
200
1450
933.95
16.57
20.96
40 Super Underwood Hardcast
220
1350
890.53
16.97
21.98
460 Rowland
230
1350
931
20.01
24.03
44 Mag low recoil
255
1264
904.88
19.75
25.89
460 Rowland
255
1300
957.16
21.36
27.39
41 mag
230
1450
1074.04
19.53
27.72
41 Mag
265
1350
1072.68
20.95
31.89
44 Mag
305
1325
1189.29
24.77
40.7
|