If there is one single case that stands out as an example of bad jurisprudence, Slaughterhouse is that case.
While there may be some confusion today over the phrase, "privileges and immunities," there was no confusion then. This was nothing more than a case where the Court refused to accept an amendment that changed the nature of federalism.
Regardless, I think you're right Bart. Gura is looking for that touchstone case that rights a grievous wrong.
|