There was one I saw recently on Gunbroker. The seller had an Pietta 1858 Remmie listed....44 cal. 8" barrel..fixed sights..nothing special - no accurizing done..in essence it was a NIB gun that is currently selling for $199 at Cabelas.
The seller had the opening bid at more than $300. In the description he wrote something like - this is not a Cabela's gun...we stopped buying guns from Cabelas because we kept having to return them...
OK....so it's worth $100+ more because you didn't get it at Cabela's?