|
Forum Rules | Firearms Safety | Firearms Photos | Links | Library | Lost Password | Email Changes |
Register | FAQ | Calendar | Search | Today's Posts | Mark Forums Read |
|
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
September 4, 2012, 06:52 PM | #1 |
Member
Join Date: February 17, 2011
Posts: 44
|
deer hunting: .223 vs 12 gauge slug
I recently traded my trusty Browning BAR .300 WM for an AR15. Now im preparing for fall deer season and I have 3 choices. The AR15, a Mini14 and a remington 1100. I would feel like a tool walking around the woods with an AR. That leaves the mini14 and the 12 guage. Keep in mind the model 1100 only shoots 2 and 3 quarter inch shells. I live in a heavily forrested area so any shot I take will most likely be less than 70 yards or so. I have no scope on either one. Any advice would be appreciated.
|
September 4, 2012, 07:03 PM | #2 |
Senior Member
Join Date: August 4, 2010
Posts: 820
|
Shoot slugs. Simple as that
|
September 4, 2012, 07:07 PM | #3 |
Junior member
Join Date: January 24, 2010
Location: South West Riverside County California
Posts: 2,763
|
Brenneke slugs for up to 70 yards.
|
September 4, 2012, 07:09 PM | #4 |
Senior Member
Join Date: February 21, 2012
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 763
|
I've taken more than a few deer with a .223.
Last year my daughter took a 4 pointer at 45 yards with an AR-15 in .223. Don't let people tell you that a .223 isn't capable of taking deer. Within 70 yards (heck within 150 yards) its quite capable of taking deer. You just have make sure you put the bullet where it needs to be for a quick kill. Now personally within 70 yards I'd go with a .223 because of the fact that I've never had great accuracy with slugs out of a shotgun at those distances. A shotgun for me is a 50yd or less deer gun. If you want a a good deer round get yourself an upper in 6.8spc or better yet for within 100 yards an upper in .30RAR. Otherwise the .223 is fine.
__________________
This is who we are, what we do. |
September 4, 2012, 07:36 PM | #5 |
Member
Join Date: February 17, 2011
Posts: 44
|
white tail .223 vs. 12 guage slug
Long story short, I'm in between dedicated deer rifles at the moment. My 3 choices for this fall are AR15, Mini14 and Remington 1100. Thats .223 or 12 guage slug. I'm leaning toward the Mini right now. Keep in mind that the Remington only shoots 2 and 3/4 inch shells. Any advice is appreciated.
|
September 4, 2012, 07:44 PM | #6 |
Moderator Emeritus
Join Date: June 25, 2008
Location: Austin, CO
Posts: 19,578
|
I'ds use a 223. I hate shooting deer slugs. Accuracy matters, power does not. A deer with a .223 hole in it's lungs will be just as dead, just as fast as a deer with a 3/4 inch hole in it's lungs.
__________________
Nobody plans to screw up their lives... ...they just don't plan not to. -Andy Stanley |
September 4, 2012, 07:48 PM | #7 |
Senior Member
Join Date: February 21, 2012
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 763
|
I'd go with the AR.
My experience with Mini-14s is that accuracy is hit or miss with those rifles. I'm not a fan of taking deer with slugs unless they're REALLY close (nothing to do with power - of which the 12ga. slug has LOADS of - and all to do with accuracy).
__________________
This is who we are, what we do. |
September 4, 2012, 08:12 PM | #8 | ||
Senior Member
Join Date: September 9, 2008
Location: Woooooshington
Posts: 1,797
|
Quote:
Quote:
C
__________________
Shoulder Drive Nicholson Club |
||
September 4, 2012, 08:41 PM | #9 | |
Moderator Emeritus
Join Date: June 25, 2008
Location: Austin, CO
Posts: 19,578
|
Quote:
My distaste for 12ga slugs isn't lack of power, it's excess. They are ridiculous overkill for whitetail deer and serve only to bruise shoulders and teach young hunters to flinch. The guns are bulky and heavy, good shells are more expensive than good rifle rounds, accuracy is marginal beyond rock throwing distance... Need I go on? Use the 12ga for what it was made for, it's a SHOTgun. Shoot SHOT out of it. Kill deer with a deer gun.
__________________
Nobody plans to screw up their lives... ...they just don't plan not to. -Andy Stanley |
|
September 4, 2012, 08:50 PM | #10 |
Senior Member
Join Date: November 26, 2008
Posts: 217
|
The slug gun's capability depend entirely on whether you have a rifled barrel and appropriate sights/scope. With both, it's a 100+ yard gun. With a smoothbore and bead, <50 yds.
A .22 would kill a deer. Poachers like them, nice and quiet. Personally I would not hunt deer with one, given other options. YMMV. |
September 4, 2012, 08:57 PM | #11 |
Senior Member
Join Date: May 30, 2010
Location: Arizona or Ohio depending
Posts: 1,021
|
What your state laws will allow and what you know you can drop him in 1.
Around here its the 12 gage slug. |
September 4, 2012, 09:07 PM | #12 |
Junior member
Join Date: October 4, 2007
Location: All the way to NEBRASKA
Posts: 8,722
|
I've no experience with slugs, and am not well versed in their capabilities, so I can't really speak to that.
My state regs require 900 ft/lbs of energy @100 yards for a rifle to be legal..... so an AR would be iffy , from a legal standpoint, depending upon the load/bullet used, barrel length, etc...... I would advise a controlled expansion bullet (I understand Nosler makes a 60gr Partition) if you go with the AR.... not condoning using an AR on deer, mind you ....... just sayin' ....... |
September 4, 2012, 09:33 PM | #13 |
Senior Member
Join Date: January 30, 2006
Posts: 1,433
|
An inexperienced deer hunter is probably more accurate with a .223 AR than a 12 ga. 1100. But, IMHO, a .223 is a bottom-end marginal for whitetail deer (at least those deer the size of Iowa whitetails). A 12 ga. slug from a smooth bore shotgun does not have to be as accurately placed as a .223 to take the deer. If a center fire rifle is an option, I would recommend a .243 Win. as the minimum. With a 12 ga. shotgun, it is hard (if not impossible) to beat a fully rifled barrel with a cantilever scope and a sabot slug ( such as those made be Remington. I've taken Iowa whitetails at well over 100 yards (standing, walking & running) with a 12 ga. 870 SP with a rifled barrel, Leupold 1 X 4 scope and 2 3/4" Remington Sabot Slugs.
Edit: Center-fire rifles are extremely limited for deer hunting in Iowa and a heart/lung/liver shot with a slug from a 2 3/4" 12 ga. is not over-kill on a mature Iowa whitetail (at least in the opinion of Iowa legislators and the DNR). In my experience (over 40 years of hunting in Iowa, Missouri, Minnesota, Colorado, Wyoming and Montana for pronghorn, whitetail, mule deer, elk, black bear and varmints) a wound from a 12 ga. slug is similar to a wound from a .243, .270, 7mm Rem Mag., 30-06, or .300 Win Mag. (depending, of course, on the range; e.g., 25 yards or 300 yards.)
__________________
Vietnam Veteran ('69-'70) NRA Life Member RMEF Life Member Last edited by lefteye; September 4, 2012 at 09:49 PM. |
September 4, 2012, 09:49 PM | #14 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: December 17, 2007
Location: SOUTHEAST, OHIO
Posts: 5,970
|
Quote:
A smoothbore 12ga. shooting 2 3/4 slugs is more then capable of killing deer at distances of 75yds. A few have been taken pushing 100yds. A rifled bbl has 100yd+- potential if the operator does his/her job. You didn't say whether your bbl was smooth or rifled but at any rate, see what slug your shotgun prefers and get proficient with it to know the drop of your slug and your capabilities. |
|
September 4, 2012, 10:15 PM | #15 |
Senior Member
Join Date: March 14, 2010
Location: Border of Idaho & Montana
Posts: 2,584
|
Either would be fine. At that range through I would go with the slugs. They will have more knock down power. The 223 will do the job but the 12ga will do it with more room for error.
__________________
Shot placement is everything! I would rather take a round of 50BMG to the foot than a 22short to the base of the skull. all 26 of my guns are 45/70 govt, 357 mag, 22 or 12 ga... I believe in keeping it simple. Wish my wife did as well... |
September 5, 2012, 03:01 AM | #16 |
Senior Member
Join Date: June 15, 2008
Location: Georgia
Posts: 10,792
|
Use the 223 rifle that is the most accurate. Probably the AR. Load it with good quality softpoint bullets and hunt with confidence. If you were hunting game larger than deer I'd recommend slugs. But a 223 will easily kill any deer on the planet within reasonable ranges. On typical size deer that means no more than 200 yards. I'd cut that range in half on some of the 300-400 lb monsters that live in some parts of the country and Canada.
As with any chambering, it is the bullet that kills. The 223 is debteable among some because they have only seen it used with varmit bullets and seen it fail on deer. Buy a bullet designed for big game and it will work fine. |
September 5, 2012, 06:39 PM | #17 |
Senior Member
Join Date: July 26, 2006
Location: Deerfield,New Hampshire
Posts: 512
|
Sounds to me you have the ideal shotgun hunting terrain.
A smoothbore 12ga. shooting 2 3/4 slugs is more then capable of killing deer at distances of 75yds. A few have been taken pushing 100yds. A rifled bbl has 100yd+- potential if the operator does his/her job. You didn't say whether your bbl was smooth or rifled but at any rate, see what slug your shotgun prefers and get proficient with it to know the drop of your slug and your capabilities. Absolutely-people who don't believe in the accuracy of smooth bores pushing a Brenneke ought to try it |
September 6, 2012, 05:37 AM | #18 |
Senior Member
Join Date: July 11, 2005
Location: Manatee County, Florida
Posts: 1,974
|
Personally, I can't take the vicious recoil of a 12 gauge slug gun. So I hunt "shotgun only" zones with a modern in-line muzzle loader which is legal within Pennsylvania.
223 can get the job done under ideal circumstances. But how often does that occur? Photo is from a private fenced hunting preserve. I was invited to their open house couple years back. I didn't book a hunt but had a great time looking at their amazing deer. Jack
__________________
Fire up the grill! Deer hunting IS NOT catch and release. |
September 6, 2012, 05:17 PM | #19 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: February 21, 2012
Location: Wisconsin
Posts: 763
|
Quote:
__________________
This is who we are, what we do. |
|
September 6, 2012, 05:24 PM | #20 | |
Moderator Emeritus
Join Date: June 25, 2008
Location: Austin, CO
Posts: 19,578
|
Quote:
Oh, and I'd take that shot in your picture at that distance with a properly loaded 223, in a heart beat.
__________________
Nobody plans to screw up their lives... ...they just don't plan not to. -Andy Stanley |
|
September 6, 2012, 05:26 PM | #21 |
Senior Member
Join Date: September 18, 2011
Location: North Idaho
Posts: 161
|
Either one. A .223 with a well placed shot and a good bullet will drop any deer that ever lived out to at least 200 yards. The 12 gauge slug will do the same thing out to about 100 yards or so (emphasis on 'well placed shot' here). Take your pick.
|
September 6, 2012, 08:05 PM | #22 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: June 15, 2008
Location: Georgia
Posts: 10,792
|
Quote:
Most people don't understand that precision shooting is MORE important in close range brush shooting. Look at Jack O'Connor's photo. That is very typical of my hunting. A high quality scope with a tackdriving, flat shooting rifle allows you to place your bullets through those small openings in the brush. A deer may have a rather large kill zone that is easier to hit out in the open at 400 yards than at 40 yards in brush because only a small portion of it is visible. A rifle with an arched trajectory is less of a problem in the open because you can always aim high and lob it in. In the brush a bullet that does not shoot laser flat will be impossible to thread through those openings. You gotta also consider a 223 has around 4 ft lbs of recoil vs a 12 slug with around 30 ft lbs of recoil. That and the cost of practice ammo and almost anyone will be a much better shot with the 223. Either is more than adequate, but precise shot placement is far more likely with the rifle round. |
|
September 6, 2012, 09:06 PM | #23 |
Senior Member
Join Date: December 13, 2009
Location: central Wisconsin
Posts: 2,324
|
Make sure the .223 is legal in your state.
|
September 7, 2012, 09:58 AM | #24 | |
Senior Member
Join Date: February 2, 2007
Location: Iowa
Posts: 2,676
|
Quote:
The answer is not a simple "use this" or use that". If the 1100 is just a good ol' bird gun with a long barrel and a bead sight then I wouldn't use it. Short barrels and rifles sights or scopes is where it's at. But then again you can't just grab the Mini and shove any old load in it and go deer hunting either. You're gonna need a "game" bullet in that gun while most of whats on the shelf are military, target or varmint oriented. All 3 of which are very poor choices. If you have a smoothbore slug barrel for that shotgun it's the best choice IMO. If legal the .223 will work given you get some good game specific ammo to shoot in it and pick you're shots. |
|
September 7, 2012, 01:48 PM | #25 |
Moderator Emeritus
Join Date: June 25, 2008
Location: Austin, CO
Posts: 19,578
|
I only hunted a couple of years with fancy slugs, killing many deer before that with $5/15 Winchesters.
As to meat damage, so far as I can tell, if you shoot meat, you damage it, if you don't you don't. From handguns, rifles, archery equipment and shotguns, I see no appreciable difference in "blood shot" meat if you shoot the meat. Shotguns certainly have penetration in spades. I've seen a regular 1oz slug hit a full grown deer in the left ham and end up just in side the right front shoulder. That's a solid 2 1/2-3 feet of penetration. Which is about 1 foot and a half more than you need. As to the weight of the guns, you've either got some heavy freaking rifles or some very light (and horrendously recoiling) shotguns. I've hunted with or used a number of different brands over the years, Savage, Ithaca, Browning, multiple Remington pumps and Autos and probably some I don't remember, most of them, with a sling and scope, weigh very near 10 pounds. I don't think I've had a rifle that weighs over 7.5. I'm not telling anyone not to use a shotgun. If that's what you like, go for it, but I'd take just about any rifle between 223 to 30-06 before I'd take a 12ga.
__________________
Nobody plans to screw up their lives... ...they just don't plan not to. -Andy Stanley |
Tags |
.223 , ar 15 , ar-15 , deer , deer hunting , mini 14 , mini14 |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
|
|