Chronic Wasting Disease

ZeroJunk · September 15, 2006, 06:26 AM

I have read that some scientist suspect that the prion responsible for CWD could be in the animal for several years before the symptoms manifest themselves.Are any of you concerned about eating elk or deer?

taylorce1 · September 15, 2006, 07:03 AM

This is the first year I will be hunting in a CWD area, I plan on getting my elk tested for CWD. I have two elk tags this year and I'll have to make sure that I don't mix the elk up when I'm processing it. I'd hate to have one test positive and the other not, if I didn't have a clue as to which meat was which I'd have to throw it all out. Good thing about Colorado is if you shoot a CWD animal they give you a refund on you tag or a later season hunt. CWD is not limited to deer and elk anymore, there was a moose that tested positive last year in Colorado.

Smokey Joe · September 17, 2006, 08:52 PM

Any deer family member can contract CWD. That is, any split-hoofed, branching-antlered mammal. Not goats. Not antelopes. They have horns, not antlers.

So. Deer, certainly. Elk, certainly. Also moose, Sika deer, Fallow deer, red stags, and any others of that family. (family Cervidae, for the biologists)

There is no proof that CWD can be passed to humans. In areas in the West where CWD has been endemic for years, the statistical occurrance of CJD (Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease, a similar disease in humans) is the same as in areas where CWD has never been found in deer.

OTOH, I sure wouldn't care to be the one person who proved that particular statistic wrong!!

Now Mad Cow disease IS transmissible from cattle to humans, but most TSE's (transmissible spongiform encephalopathies--aren't you glad you asked!) are species-specific. The best example we have is Sheep Scrapie, which is the sheep TSE, and which we have known about for hundreds of years. And shepherds do NOT get sheep scrapie. So the contention that the deer TSE, CWD, is not transmissible to humans is probably correct. However (there is always that darn "however!") it is impossible to prove a negative. We'll just have to wait and see.

As to how long is the incubation period, ZeroJunk's question, that isn't known for sure. It IS known that CJD in humans can have an incubation period of several years. Probably the incubation for CWD is shorter in deer, with their shorter life span.

All of these TSE's are hideous, and yes, I am concerned. But for the present I'm still eating deer meat.

September 15, 2006, 06:26 AM	#1
ZeroJunk Senior Member Join Date: August 14, 2006 Location: Browns Summit NC Posts: 2,589	Chronic Wasting Disease I have read that some scientist suspect that the prion responsible for CWD could be in the animal for several years before the symptoms manifest themselves.Are any of you concerned about eating elk or deer?

September 17, 2006, 08:52 PM	#3
Smokey Joe Senior Member Join Date: July 14, 2001 Location: State of Confusion Posts: 2,106	Deer family members Any deer family member can contract CWD. That is, any split-hoofed, branching-antlered mammal. Not goats. Not antelopes. They have horns, not antlers. So. Deer, certainly. Elk, certainly. Also moose, Sika deer, Fallow deer, red stags, and any others of that family. (family Cervidae, for the biologists) There is no proof that CWD can be passed to humans. In areas in the West where CWD has been endemic for years, the statistical occurrance of CJD (Creutzfeldt-Jakob Disease, a similar disease in humans) is the same as in areas where CWD has never been found in deer. OTOH, I sure wouldn't care to be the one person who proved that particular statistic wrong!! Now Mad Cow disease IS transmissible from cattle to humans, but most TSE's (transmissible spongiform encephalopathies--aren't you glad you asked!) are species-specific. The best example we have is Sheep Scrapie, which is the sheep TSE, and which we have known about for hundreds of years. And shepherds do NOT get sheep scrapie. So the contention that the deer TSE, CWD, is not transmissible to humans is probably correct. However (there is always that darn "however!") it is impossible to prove a negative. We'll just have to wait and see. As to how long is the incubation period, ZeroJunk's question, that isn't known for sure. It IS known that CJD in humans can have an incubation period of several years. Probably the incubation for CWD is shorter in deer, with their shorter life span. All of these TSE's are hideous, and yes, I am concerned. But for the present I'm still eating deer meat. __________________ God Bless America --Smokey Joe

September 15, 2006, 07:03 AM	#2
taylorce1 Senior Member Join Date: November 18, 2005 Location: On the Santa Fe Trail Posts: 8,250	This is the first year I will be hunting in a CWD area, I plan on getting my elk tested for CWD. I have two elk tags this year and I'll have to make sure that I don't mix the elk up when I'm processing it. I'd hate to have one test positive and the other not, if I didn't have a clue as to which meat was which I'd have to throw it all out. Good thing about Colorado is if you shoot a CWD animal they give you a refund on you tag or a later season hunt. CWD is not limited to deer and elk anymore, there was a moose that tested positive last year in Colorado.