January 16, 2012, 10:42 AM
|
#21
|
Senior Member
Join Date: June 4, 2006
Location: West Virginia
Posts: 2,258
|
This isn't the one I was looking for but it's basically the same result.
Quote:
To Kill A Primer
By Stu Farish
A lot of people hold to the notion that WD-40 and some other solvents will easily deactivate any primer. I got to wondering just how true this was in fact.
It seems that somewhere along the way, the companies started doing something that seals the compound a lot better. People have soaked them in WD-40, penetrating oil, water, for several days and then found that they fired just fine.
I happened to have some primed 30-06 brass boxed up. I had some loaded up, decided on a different load & pulled the bullets & powder. I decided to do a test of my own. Say 5 cases of each thing I try. They've been sitting around, primed but unloaded, in an ammo box for a year or more. So I can use 5 as is, 5 with WD-40, 5 with water, 5 with Dillon Case Lube, 5 with motor oil, 5 with Kroil, and 5 with Break-Free penetrating oil. Soak them for 4 or 5 days and then see how many go bang.
I have 5 cases each:
Untreated
Liquid wrench
WD-40
Rem Oil (spray)
Dillon Case Lube
Water
Alcohol
Kroil
Each batch of 5 cases were treated, then placed mouth up inside a plastic ammo box. The box is now closed, which should help reduce any evaporation.
This batch happens to be Winchester Large Rifle primers. Yep, it'd be worthwhile to try a bunch of different ones to see if I get different results. I'd expect the same brand to respond about the same, ie WSR I'd expect to do about the same as WLR. But Federal & Remington primers may respond very differently. I'll probably try to continue this as time permits, do one type at a time & compare the results.
Day 1, after 24 hours:
Untreated - normal discharge. Could see smoke exit the rifle muzzle.
Liquid wrench - Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Smoke visible inside case.
WD-40 - Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Smoke visible inside case.
Rem Oil (spray) - Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Smoke visible inside case.
Dillon Case Lube - Very Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Slight trace of smoke visible inside case.
Water - Very Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Slight trace of smoke visible inside case.
Alcohol - Very Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Slight trace of smoke visible inside case.
Kroil - Weak. primer ignited, but could not see smoke exit muzzle. Smoke visible inside case.
In short, all primers ignited to some degree
|
Here is the link if you want to see all five days.
http://www.predatormastersforums.com/killprimers.shtml
__________________
I don't ever remember being absent minded.
|
|
|