The Firing Line Forums - View Single Post

SaxonPig · May 24, 2014, 07:52 AM

I would also prefer the Python but they currently sell for $2,000+ so a Python may not be a good choice for a casual range gun.

The K frame S&W (19/66) is a classic revolver. I personally don't like the look of stainless but it is more practical on a working gun.

Be aware there are two Troopers. The pre-1969 Trooper has the same action as the Python. The Mk III Trooper is a completely different revolver. Most Colt lovers prefer the earlier version but the Mk III is a perfectly good pistol.

Comparing the Colt to the Smith most shooters will vote for the S&W. You have tried the Colt and like it. Either will do what you want it to do just fine.

The Colt is built on a larger frame than the K frame S&W, so it's a bit sturdier. But it's also a bit larger and heavier.

Colt prices are insane since Colt pulled out of the handgun market a few years ago. But if you like the Trooper you shot then look for one. Note that the shorter the barrel the bigger the price. The 2" (or 2.5" as the case may be) guns are always in high demand and command more money. A 4" model will be cheaper and easier to shoot. But buy what makes you happy. Life's too short to do otherwise.

May 24, 2014, 07:52 AM	#5
SaxonPig Senior Member Join Date: April 24, 2006 Posts: 1,900	I would also prefer the Python but they currently sell for $2,000+ so a Python may not be a good choice for a casual range gun. The K frame S&W (19/66) is a classic revolver. I personally don't like the look of stainless but it is more practical on a working gun. Be aware there are two Troopers. The pre-1969 Trooper has the same action as the Python. The Mk III Trooper is a completely different revolver. Most Colt lovers prefer the earlier version but the Mk III is a perfectly good pistol. Comparing the Colt to the Smith most shooters will vote for the S&W. You have tried the Colt and like it. Either will do what you want it to do just fine. The Colt is built on a larger frame than the K frame S&W, so it's a bit sturdier. But it's also a bit larger and heavier. Colt prices are insane since Colt pulled out of the handgun market a few years ago. But if you like the Trooper you shot then look for one. Note that the shorter the barrel the bigger the price. The 2" (or 2.5" as the case may be) guns are always in high demand and command more money. A 4" model will be cheaper and easier to shoot. But buy what makes you happy. Life's too short to do otherwise.