At the present time I have two a cabelas 1851 steel frame navy colt .36 and a cabelas remmington New Police .36 (I the 36's)
Personally I like both and would not give up either. I like the quickness of the remmington and the way it handles, and everyone will tell you about the handling of the '51 navy. On the other hand for long range (75yards plus) I use the navy instead of the solid frame remmington, for what ever reason, I shoot more accurately with the navy (been using one since I was 18 that might have something to do with it) but I still will not take for either of them.