Con: A few too many pockmarks/puncture marks, makes it look like it went through a patch of briers, thorns or cacti instead of an occasional run in with a strand of barbed wire.
Pro: I really like how dark the stain is and the color of it. On this particular holster, the dark stain is a saving grace from the large number of scars.
I think that the mild dents/depressions in the leather look better than the razor cuts, slices and puncture holes.
How it looks grows on you. Good job overall Mike!