View Single Post
Old March 10, 2008, 12:30 AM   #21
Hugh Damright
Senior Member
 
Join Date: June 5, 2004
Posts: 611
Quote:
What, say, Illinois bans ALL guns.
I think that would go beyond an intrastate affair and become a union/federal affair. On the other hand, if they banned some guns, or required trigger locks, I don't see how that could interfere with the other States, with the Union, or with federal powers.


Quote:
So, do you think the Federal government should intervene and override the state laws? Expand on this basic rights issue if you'd like or use another example to debate.
I do not believe that a limited federal government can have a general power to intervene in all matters. Nor do I believe that a limited federal government can have such a broad and general power as "protector of rights". I think that federal powers to intervene and override state law should be limited and enumerated powers, and that any such powers must be freely delegated by the States.
Hugh Damright is offline  
 
Page generated in 0.03628 seconds with 8 queries