It seems the Garand is the winner. But let me dispell any doubts that I can own one in NY.
The En-Bloc clip is a 'clip', and considered an internal magazine; therefor, it is not included in the ban, although loading 8 rounds would be a illegal.
It is also considerned an antique, well, most of them are that old. 50 years old I think to be considered one.
I think that, given the unanimous decision, I will be saving for an M1.
And I will NOT pay for the firearm in a way that NY gets any cash.
Long live the 2nd!