My advice won't be worth much, because I have never owned or shot any of the shotguns you listed. I do own an older Remington Wingmaster 870, that has had 1,000s of rounds go thru it without problems.
I got the wingmaster for "3 Gun" with 18.5" barrel. I now have 6 (Yes, I got another this week) barrels, running from 18.5" to 34". Way too many corn cobs, and stocks. You won't go wrong with a good pump with extra barrels (IMO,
).
If you make a mistake and want to get something else, you might consider the resale value of the guns on your list.
When your or families a$$e$ are on the line, do you really need to weary about the budget?
Personally I like a S&W Model 25 in 45 Colt for HD, But that's just me.