Dave,
You're right, to each his or her own. Not trying to start an argument, just pointing out that semi-autos do have their pros (and cons!).
For example, I'm sure in the course of your training you put the rookies through the one-handed drill. Doing the Linda Hamilton method (or the put-the-shotgun-between-your-legs drill) can be learned but a semi-auto makes it a lot easier.
Also, consider the difficulty with operating a pump gun in rollover prone or the supine position. Not impossible but a semi-auto makes it easier. Some people have trouble with using a pump gun in the standard prone position. Training can fix that but again a semi-auto makes it easy.
Short-shucking will plague novice pump gun users as well. Again, training can fix this situation. Semi-autos don't suffer from this problem.
Most (if not all) the reputable semi-auto shotguns will cycle light loads without a hitch. The inertia-operated guns, when not burdened with excessive bells and whistles, will cycle air. The gas guns will do the same, if kept clean and in good condition.
That said, IMHO a pump makes the switch-to-slug drill easier. They are cheaper and you don't have to keep them as clean (when comparing them to a gas gun) for reliable functioning.
So there are good reasons to pick either shotgun -- if you go with the semi-auto, keep it clean (gas gun) or keep it close to stock (inertia gun) and be prepared to spend a bit of money. If you go with the pump, you must train harder but you can save a good bit of cash.
Justin
[This message has been edited by jthuang (edited May 22, 2000).]
[This message has been edited by jthuang (edited May 22, 2000).]
|