The Firing Line Forums - View Single Post - Chambering problems with Winchester 40S&W

Big Bunny · September 22, 2000, 05:45 AM

Anyone out ther had problems with +5% non-chambering with new Winchester brand S&W 40s using a black "petal" type metal jacket?

Well we have had problems with brass 'bulges' way over spec near the head, leading to stoppages in Glock pistols on our range.

Yes...well -
I too made the usual flippant comments to the people concerned over lack of cleaning and 'Gaston's revenge' and happily took the rounds home for a check, to report back on any findings.
To my surprise they WERE way over spec and would not chamber even in my CZ-75 either.
Hell!!

Now we are talking seriously here. A stoppage while on patrol could lead to loss of life with these people I feel. Also the ammo is not cheap here with the aussie 'zloti' dollar at near 50c/USD and a Winch US imported box costing nearly $40 for 50 carts in local sports stores.
I am appalled at possible US factory poor Winchester Q/Control, but is this usual for them? There was no obvious damage to the patrol rounds, but the teflon lead target L/Enforcement ammo round has similar problems but it is of low quality ove4rall this can be expected so not such a problem on the range - and could even be good training!
Any comment would be appreciated as this is a "no duff" call and could affect morale.
I have advised for them to check each round for chambering in a disassembled barrel/chamber before use or magazine filling...(as we shooters do in some hunting ammo).
The disclaimer on each packet is fairly all encompassing as regards liability.But it should never have happened, to hell with liability etc - I feel.
Batch number and ID is available. Do I report direct or through channels. Advice please

BB

------------------
If we shooting sportspersons don't hang together... we will all hang separately !
Never knock another's different shooting interest or discipline...REMEMBER we are all but leaves on the same tree of freedom.

September 22, 2000, 05:45 AM	#1
Big Bunny Senior Member Join Date: August 9, 1999 Location: New South Wales - Australia Posts: 605	Anyone out ther had problems with +5% non-chambering with new Winchester brand S&W 40s using a black "petal" type metal jacket? Well we have had problems with brass 'bulges' way over spec near the head, leading to stoppages in Glock pistols on our range. Yes...well - I too made the usual flippant comments to the people concerned over lack of cleaning and 'Gaston's revenge' and happily took the rounds home for a check, to report back on any findings. To my surprise they WERE way over spec and would not chamber even in my CZ-75 either. Hell!! Now we are talking seriously here. A stoppage while on patrol could lead to loss of life with these people I feel. Also the ammo is not cheap here with the aussie 'zloti' dollar at near 50c/USD and a Winch US imported box costing nearly $40 for 50 carts in local sports stores. I am appalled at possible US factory poor Winchester Q/Control, but is this usual for them? There was no obvious damage to the patrol rounds, but the teflon lead target L/Enforcement ammo round has similar problems but it is of low quality ove4rall this can be expected so not such a problem on the range - and could even be good training! Any comment would be appreciated as this is a "no duff" call and could affect morale. I have advised for them to check each round for chambering in a disassembled barrel/chamber before use or magazine filling...(as we shooters do in some hunting ammo). The disclaimer on each packet is fairly all encompassing as regards liability.But it should never have happened, to hell with liability etc - I feel. Batch number and ID is available. Do I report direct or through channels. Advice please BB ------------------ If we shooting sportspersons don't hang together... we will all hang separately ! Never knock another's different shooting interest or discipline...REMEMBER we are all but leaves on the same tree of freedom.