There are always trade-offs and the claim the rifled barrel are more acccurate, is generally true. However, as
seansean1444 you will kill deer in the "normal" ranges of our Midwest. Most of my shots have been in the 60yd. or less range. I had a BPS with rifled barrel and a smooth bore 1100. Both killed there share of deer but eventually settled on my smooth bore and sold the BPS. ...
Your money, your call. ...
Be Safe !!!