Originally Posted by TunnelRat
So anyway, I sit with both in front of me dry-firing like a mad man and scratching my head. I doubt I'll ever figure it out completely. Anyone else feel my pain?
No, I feel very comfortable with either type of pistol.
You are doing way too much analysis of way too little difference. At real self defense ranges, differences in speed and accuracy between the different lengths and weights of trigger pulls is probably not going to be significant. Settling on a gun that you shoot well and practicing regularly is probably much more meaningful than the type of equipment that you choose.