#1 for fondling: standard model EAA Witnesses (never owned a proper CZ75. Some day...). Nicknamed "the twins" - a .45 and a 10mm. The Hunter is a bit too noseheavy. Still get it out to admire from time to time though. They're also my most natural shooters. They just "fit" me.
#2 Sig P238
The Speed Six would be higher on the list if I carried it but it's usually put away and not available for fondling. I really like my compact 1911 but it doesn't get the loving attention that the Witnesses do.