1. I am not the one doing this one handed that was another poster. Glad you guys are able to suggest things and help him though.
2. My speed loaders require me to twist to release the cartridges. If I were to be able to simply push down like with the safariland this might just be a non issue. I will have to look into those.
My only reason to remotly consider this is to achieve a faster reload. If I am going to possibly achieve that but cause my Gun to be less reliable with a bent moon clip then it is a no brainer which way I would go.