It only makes sense if you are willing to ignore the inconvenient existence of the second amendment.
I have no idea what you mean. The Second Amendment does not, has not, and will not guarantee unregulated access to and use of all arms. It is pointless to pretend otherwise.
In any event, I think the problem is that some of us tend to think that in personal discussion and in the political realm that anyone who does not share every view we hold must want to ban all guns. I don't see much of that (though those people exist, of course).
Generally, I hear a lot of folk who recognize the Second Amendment and its attendant rights, don't wish to ban guns, but want to discuss what, if anything, is rational to do.