It is hard to discuss performance based on how far they ran. It should be discussed related more on did it exit, how much penetration, and what happened when it hit bone. Sounds like one did what it should, but the other turned hitting bone. Only you looking at the animal knows if it turned too much.
Basically, they sound ok, but I would be more carefu of the deer angle to you.
My slug hit heart/ backside shoulder doe went 50 yards with a broke shoulder and a heart that looked like Swiss cheese.