I'd actually be quite happy if all my guns were stolen.
Providing I got back the money I paid for them all I could use the hind sight I know now to make a few different choices.
I'd replace my Remington 870 with an 11-87.
My Tikka T3 in 223, with a heavy barrel something in 204Ruger or a 22-250.
I'd get another CZ American in 17HMR though, I love that gun.
My 303 with a 308 or a 243, probably a Tikka.
But it'd be a toss up with my Remington 597 if I replace it with another or get a CZ American or trainer in 22lr. I might just get both to ease all the stress I would've been under