I am not even taking the time to read your quibling nonsense and will only comment on two things.
The first is you continue to argue that neither is most likely to intantly stop the threat. Your lame retort is neither.
My answer was neither due to fringe hit / B zone at best. You'll get some pellets in the lung but that doesn't translate to an INSTANT STOP.
I know and knew when the question was fabricated that neither was likely to put an immediat end to the threat, BUT THAT WAS NOT THE QUESTION. The question was which of the two was more likely than the other.
The other item is quite simple. Have you ever pulled the trigger in a real world in-home encounter with one or multiple bad guys? I don't want any BS about training or video games.
Enjoy your thanksgiving. I get to mow the yards.