I like the 357mag but its ranking is due to its popularity and use years ago
It's easy to be #1 if its used more and longer for a period in time. I suspect that ranking will change due to the fact the 357mag isn't used hardly at all any more in LE. If it is so good, and offered a clear advantage, wouldn't the FBI and LE still be using it???
It's at the top of that FBI whatever list for fatal shooting incidents (for whatever that is worth).