You are the only one who can answer that question for yourself.
Grips are like shoes, they must fit.
Many people like Hogues. That brand is just all wrong for my hands.
For my Ruger Redhawk I went through, at least, six brands and styles of grips before settling on Pachymar Presentations. They fit me, allow control, do not punish and have just the right amount of softness for gripping but don't tear the skin.
That is me. Use the 'try' grips in your local gun shop and/or be prepared to spend some money on various grips until you find your perfect fit.