Love them. Now they don't do kind of an ongoing road test, but straight reviews only. They also don't receive the firearms directly from the dealer. The used guns they review tend to be from locals - often on loan only for the test.
They got into a bit of kerfluffle when the flunked a Fulton Arms Titan, and have given the M&Pc a "D" because of feeding issues. Often they'll say it flunked or did poorly because of a factor and send it off to repair and rediscuss it.
I like their reviews and their "best buys" which aren't necessarily the best of a comparable group, just the best for the price.