Read that in context. Hogdogs was talking about a Taurus Judge loaded with Bird Shot being not worth squat.
Maybe that's where the disagreement comes from.
I didn't place the statement in any context other than what was said.
I believe the reference was a pharmacist whose shot disabled a robber and left him lying completely incapacitated until he came back and unnecessarily shot him again.
IF he was using birdshot, then maybe The Judge so loaded is more potent than we thought--- up real close, anyway.