Josh Blackman has a few things to say about the ruling, here
I should also say that this opinion was entirely expected by Kilmer and Gura. They filed their notice of appeal almost as soon as the Judge issued his opinion. Check out the Docket
to see what I mean.
Over in the 6th column, you will see that 4 of us hit PACER within minutes of each other. Each time, a new entry had been made.