I went through the process for about 12 months. Shot quite a few and because of light weight and size decided to go with the 380. Owned P3at, fired the Kahr 380 (very nice), LCP (liked it also) but none were in the ballpark IMHO with the Sig P238. I love it, shoots awesome and carries great. I now have the extended mag to go with it and like it a ton.
Next choice for me would likely be the Kimber Solo or more likely the Kahr 9. But, the Sig with Buffalo Bore or Corbons should do the trick.