I dont' know about most folks but I am not taking a shot at 200 rds with the 17 hmr or the 22 win mag.
and the OP discussion was 75yds to 125yds
at that distance the MOA of a pie plate is negligible between the rounds.
"Did I kill it sub MOA dead or MOA dead?....I gotsta KNOW" :barf:
Bottom line at those distances most likely you are gonna hit what you are aiming at.....Question is do you want a light weight bullet or a really really light weight bullet
Two is One, One is None