First, kudos to Judge Murphy for upholding constitutional law.
"The Bill of Rights exists to protect people from government, and does not exist to sanction government to do certain things to people."
Absolutely spot-on and something too many judges ignore.
This is quite a good analysis by a municipal court judge. If the city appeals, which I doubt they will, I think they'll be shot out of the saddle.
BillCA in CA (Unfortunately)