I'll weigh in for the Winchester 1300. Mine's been a fine tool with no hang-ups of any kind.
It's advantages for me: Smooth as silk action out of the box and ever since, fastest follow-up shot of any pump because of the assisted cycling design, and safety and release where I like them best (if only because of years of use with it).
All three brands make good tools. All three make occasional clunkers, with ample horror stories available all around for anyone who wants to make his decision based on anecdotes.
The gun you buy (the very gun) needs to be thoroughly tested before you put your life in its hands, regardless of brand.