PDA

View Full Version : RRA Chrome carrier groups?


droptrd
September 5, 2012, 08:28 AM
Finally got my rifle from RRA. I was kinda bummed to find out that on 7-10-12 RRA discontinued chrome bolt carrier groups as part of the operator specials:(

They say waiting for the chrome parts was backing them up more than they already are so they cut them from the specials.

Oh well.....

madcratebuilder
September 5, 2012, 09:35 AM
Why do you want a chrome BCG? All current M16's use a phosphate BCG. No chrome BCG's are used in deployed rifles, training use only.

I don't find a chrome BCG to be that easier to clean or add any reliability.

droptrd
September 5, 2012, 10:13 AM
All my chrome lined barrels are easier to clean soo I figured...:D

learningcurve
September 5, 2012, 12:58 PM
Well I have a Chrome BCG and I love it compared to my other BCG which is the standard black one. I can have the chrome one done in a very short time compared to my black one.

Technosavant
September 5, 2012, 01:08 PM
I have a couple rifles with fully chromed BCGs and a few with the more traditional phosphate exterior/chrome interior finish.

The fully chromed ones are indeed easier to clean- they wipe down really nicely. However, I don't know that they make much, if any, difference in reliability. The fully chromed ones look really nasty after a mag or two of suppressed shooting... that bright chrome shows the gunk so incredibly well.

learningcurve
September 5, 2012, 03:27 PM
Yes it is true that the chrome does get dirty quickly it seems but I wonder if that isnt due to the black not showing the same amount of residue. I dont mind the dirty look to be honest I didnt buy the rifle for the chrome BCG it was something I noticed after I got it home. I just got the one I got because it was the one I wanted at the time and I liked the company.

Technosavant
September 5, 2012, 07:17 PM
Yes it is true that the chrome does get dirty quickly it seems but I wonder if that isnt due to the black not showing the same amount of residue.

I'm sure that's the case; a white car looks messier than a brown one when driven down the same dirt road. The chromed bolt carrier just looks gross after a few rounds when the darker phosphated carrier doesn't look quite as bad.

Both work equally well, the chromed one cleans up a shade more easily (but then, the inside of the phosphated carriers, when chromed, clean up just as easily and that's the important part anyway).

learningcurve
September 5, 2012, 07:19 PM
Yea that is very true. I like both my BCGs and rifles they go in. Both are accurate as I make them so that never has been a issue when I recommend brands to buddies of mine.

Sent from my SPH-L710 using Tapatalk 2

madcratebuilder
September 6, 2012, 08:31 AM
Both work equally well, the chromed one cleans up a shade more easily (but then, the inside of the phosphated carriers, when chromed, clean up just as easily and that's the important part anyway).

+100

I have never encounter a carrier that was not chromed in the piston area. This is where they get dirty and even the dirtiest BC is easy to clean with the cleaning tools available today. The C.A.T. M4 cleaning tool makes short work of any bolt and carrier.

http://i32.photobucket.com/albums/d37/madcratebuilder/AR15/bhcatm4.png

bluto
September 6, 2012, 10:25 PM
My order from RRA also included the chrome BCG and , like the OP, they discontinued it while I was waiting for them to ship my upper. I ended up using a Loki Nickel Boron BCG and am very happy with it. Absolutely zero
malfunctions during the first 300 rounds using Win., Am Eagle, Federal, and some mystery milsurp ammo.

sailskidrive
September 8, 2012, 11:05 AM
FWIW:

RRA chrome plated bolt carriers are NOT made from #158 Carpenters steel.

I bought one a while ago and later called their help desk; it took a while but eventually they confirmed that all of their BCGs are 8620.

I personally prefer the NiB treated carriers, far easier to clean up than chrome and you can practically run them almost dry.


http://i669.photobucket.com/albums/vv54/sailskidrive/photo4.jpg

Marquezj16
September 9, 2012, 11:14 PM
RRA chrome plated bolt carriers are NOT made from #158 Carpenters steel.

I bought one a while ago and later called their help desk; it took a while but eventually they confirmed that all of their BCGs are 8620.


If you check around, most carriers are made of 8620. It's only the bolt that is made of carpenter No. 158 steel.

Here's a link that describes both Colt and RRA BCGs.

http://www.pkfirearms.com/Bolt_Assemblies/26/c

Technosavant
September 10, 2012, 09:09 AM
The bolt carrier, although important, is not as prone to failure as the bolt if not made from 158 Carpenter steel. Generally, as long as the gas key doesn't come loose, the carrier isn't likely to be an issue.

For the bolt it can be more of a problem because of the tendency for low quality bolts to split at the cam pin hole.

sailskidrive
September 12, 2012, 08:40 AM
If you check around, most carriers are made of 8620. It's only the bolt that is made of carpenter No. 158 steel.


I wrote "BCG", not "carrier".

Marquezj16
September 12, 2012, 09:22 AM
Check first sentence.

RRA chrome plated bolt carriers are NOT made from #158 Carpenters steel.

Notice "group" is not in the sentence.

Check second sentence.

I bought one a while ago and later called their help desk; it took a while but eventually they confirmed that all of their BCGs are 8620.

Incorrect, the carrier is made of 8620. The bolt is carpenter 158. Bolt carrier group means the carrier, firing pin and bolt.

RRA AR15 Bolt Group Assembly The RRA AR15 bolt group is machined from 8620 carbon steel, that is heat treated. Exterior of carrier is parkerized and interior is chrome-lined. Uses a Mil-Spec gas key that is chrome-lined, heat treated and secured to the carrier with Grade 8 fasteners that are properly staked. The bolt assembly is machined from Carpenter No. 158® steel, and has a tool steel extractor that is machined from bar stock.

sailskidrive
September 12, 2012, 10:07 AM
You're completely missing the point. A while back I bought a chrome plated RRA BCG, I called the customer service line and after a quite some time they confirmed that the entire BCG, meaning bolt, pin, key, and carrier, were made from 8620. It is possible that misinformation was conveyed... And I can see from your post that they now have actual useful information regarding the materials used available on the website.