PDA

View Full Version : Tactics against an obnoxious grandma


JohnH1963
June 10, 2009, 07:25 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5yWaE8tTlsc

Now this, in my opinion, is a prime example of taking things way too far with weaponry. This woman is obviously very weak and, at one point, the officer pushes the woman 10 feet away. There is no question that the officer could easily overpower the woman and handcuff her.

I dont believe the officer, or any citizen for that matter, would be justified to use a taser, handgun or any type of weaponry against someone who is this weak.

As a regular citizen, if I came upon an obnoxious elderly woman that grabbed and pushed me and I used a taser, then I would be taken to jail for assault and battery. How could I convince any judge or jury that I had the right to use a taser even if she did push me?

wickedrider
June 10, 2009, 08:28 PM
Thanks for being the one to post. This whole video puts whatever jurisdiction this is in a very bad light. To top it off, the Lt or whatever rank the officer is, attempts justifies the whole thing.

gregdry
June 10, 2009, 08:56 PM
I disagree. When a person is being defiant, beligerent, and will not "settle down" after repeated warnings by the police, age does not matter - the officer was quite justified. Sure, he could have easily overpowered her. But can you imagine the lawsuits that would follow if she, having fallen, happened to break her hip? He chose the only option which would prevent him from having to physically take her down. Since when do we have such sympathy for people who are being totally obnoxious???? She was stopped by the patrolman, and very uncooperative - she deserves what she got. (Frankly, she may have been playing it up just so she could get lots of mug time on TV. It worked. Yea, she's 72 years old; even more reason: she's old enough to know better!):):)

VA9mm
June 10, 2009, 08:59 PM
Comply with the officers commands and you won't get tazed.

Beentown71
June 10, 2009, 09:24 PM
DON'T TAZE ME DUDE!!!:p Sorry had too.

Beentown

hogdogs
June 10, 2009, 09:30 PM
He never had to let her off the hood! If that big cop couldn't handle the ol' gal, I would hate to see him trying to keep his gun from a fighting 18 year old 6'4" muscle bound thug!
Brent

wickedrider
June 10, 2009, 09:31 PM
Please, the only weapon that grandma had was her mouth. The LEO needs a course in professionalism.

hoytinak
June 10, 2009, 09:31 PM
If she would have listened to the officer and complied in the first place she wouldn't have gotten tazed.

gregdry
June 10, 2009, 09:48 PM
Shocking...just shocking! :eek::eek::confused:

Deaf Smith
June 10, 2009, 10:02 PM
In the hospital where my wife works they have belligerent old people all the time there.

Now I've never heard and she has never seen or heard of them tass anyone.

Now how can hospitals control old people without injuring them but the cops can't?

How?

Well they hold onto the old peoples arms. Yes they can struggle, or even bite, but usually they cannot do much of anything effective.

You do not use a joint lock on them, nor any kind of trauma. But you can hold them till backup comes.

The officer was a stupid borderline bully jackass. It was totally unnecessary.

Ok?

Hornett
June 10, 2009, 10:11 PM
When I see these videos and the ones like it, I just can't help but try to get into the head of the woman.
Unfortunately, I just can't.
I have been pulled over a couple of times and I have even been really curt to an officer once or twice. But, I always comply with any request and for sure a shouted command.
I don't believe this officer could have done anything to diffuse this situation.
If he had let her go, he would not be doing his job.
If he had tackled her he probably have hurt her worse than the taser: bruises, broken bones, cuts and scrapes would make him look really bad in a court room.
With the taser, I would think he was risking giving the grandma a heart attack.

No one knows why she got pulled over, but she was out of her car. I have never been asked by an officer to leave my car. This makes me think she was already in pretty deep trouble, but I may be wrong.

It really upsets me to think that people act like she did. It makes the policeman edgy and grouchy for the next traffic stop, which might be me. :eek:
Probably, the officer used too much force, I don't know, but, please don't defend her beahvior. It was ridiculous.

hogdogs
June 10, 2009, 10:51 PM
Stop was for speeding I heard...
Brent

Sixer
June 10, 2009, 11:13 PM
I like how he yells at her to "GET ON THE GROUND" as she is incapacitated and falling! I guess she learned her lesson the hard way.

The cop needs to be a bit more careful though... If he keeps tazing old ladies, eventually one of them is going to have a stroke or heart failure.

Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.

tmd11111
June 10, 2009, 11:24 PM
Before you make judgement on who was right and who was wrong you should get the Paul Harvey version (the rest of the story).

Seems that evening after Granny got tazes she was all over the 10 o'clock news telling all of Austin how the cops ruffed her up for no reason. She went on and on about how it was unprovoked and how cooperative she was. "Why I'm just an innocent old lady" and "the big bad cop was mean to me for no reason what so ever".

Well boys and girls, as soon as the PD released the video granny went into hiding and now refuses to do any more interviews. Go Figure......

Kind of make you wonder What the Heck Was She Thinking..........

Capt Charlie
June 10, 2009, 11:28 PM
Even though the press was careful not to present the whole video, and after 32 years in professional, full time LE, I have to agree that use of a Taser was somewhat over the top.

Even so, I fail to see how this affects our Tactics and Training, and this is most certainly going to erupt into nothing more than a simple cop bashing thread.

Closed, because it really has little bearing on the focus of this forum.